Top Writing Feedback Approaches

Feedback in language learning, especially when it comes to writing, is a critical component of the teaching process.

We all know how crucial it is to provide effective feedback that not only corrects mistakes but also encourages students to improve and understand the nuances of the target language.

Below are five techniques that I've found to be particularly effective in the comprehension-based language classroom.

1. Balancing Holistic and Specific Feedback

When it comes to feedback, striking the right balance between holistic and specific comments is key.

Holistic feedback looks at the overall quality of the writing – its flow, coherence, and overall effectiveness in conveying the intended message. It's about giving an overall impression of the student's work, rather than nitpicking every single error.

This type of feedback is particularly encouraging for students as it acknowledges their effort in creating a piece of writing in a foreign language.

On the other hand, specific feedback focuses on particular aspects of the language, such as grammar, vocabulary, and syntax. It addresses the exact points where a student might be struggling.

For instance, if a student consistently misuses past tense, point it out and provide correct examples. This approach helps students to understand their mistakes and learn the correct forms.

Combining these two feedback types provides a comprehensive overview of the student’s work.

It shows them where they are doing well and where they need to improve, without overwhelming them with corrections.

2. Providing Models and Exemplars

We often forget how important it is for students to know what good writing looks like.

Providing models and exemplars of well-written texts can be incredibly beneficial.

These examples give students a clear idea of the expectations and goals for their own writing. It's like showing them a roadmap of where they need to go.

For example, if you're teaching Spanish and the assignment is to write a descriptive paragraph, provide a well-written sample paragraph.

Discuss what makes it effective – how it uses adjectives, the flow of the sentences, and the vivid imagery it creates.

Encourage students to analyze these models and identify the techniques they can use in their writing.

3. Encouraging Peer Feedback and Revision

Peer feedback is a fantastic way for students to learn from each other.

It helps them to engage more deeply with the learning material and to see their work from another perspective.

Organizing structured peer editing activities where students can give and receive feedback is a great way to facilitate this.

In these sessions, students can point out what they liked about each other's work and suggest improvements.

It's important to guide them on how to give constructive feedback.

For example, instead of saying, "This sentence is wrong," they could say, "This sentence could be clearer if you used the past tense."

Peer feedback not only helps students improve their writing but also develops their critical thinking and analytical skills.

4. Utilizing Digital Tools for Feedback

The use of digital tools and platforms in the classroom has opened up new avenues for providing feedback.

Tools like Google Docs allow you to add comments and annotations directly onto the student's work.

This makes it easier to point out specific areas that need attention and to offer suggestions for improvement.

On top of that, digital tools can facilitate asynchronous feedback, where students can review your comments at their own pace and time.

This flexibility is often less intimidating for students, allowing them to digest the feedback more effectively.

Additionally, it creates a record of their progress, which can be motivating for students to see how much they've improved over time.

5. One-on-One Conferences for Personalized Feedback

Finally, nothing beats the effectiveness of personalized, one-on-one feedback.

Scheduling individual conferences with students to discuss their writing provides an opportunity to address their specific needs and concerns.

During these sessions, you can delve deeper into areas where the student struggles and offer tailored advice.

These meetings also allow you to understand your students' thought processes, which can be insightful in helping them improve.

It also shows students that you are invested in their learning and development, which can be a significant motivational boost.

Remember, the goal of feedback is not just to correct mistakes but to guide students towards better understanding and mastery of the language.

Happy Comprehensible Input!

Have you taken our CI Proficiency Quiz yet? Find out where you are in your CI journey towards mastery. What are you waiting for?